The Reports
"When a Reddit user drops 'TraderScale is a scam' in a trading forum, we pay attention. Not because one comment proves anything — but because we've seen this pattern before."
First it's one complaint. Then five. Then a hundred. By the time everyone knows, traders have already lost thousands.
Today, we're documenting what users are saying about TraderScale. Not to condemn them without evidence — but to give you the information you need BEFORE you spend money on their challenge.
Unlike verified firms like Apex Trader Funding that have paid out $150M+ to traders, TraderScale is accumulating complaints with limited evidence of successful withdrawals.
We've been tracking prop firm complaints for years. We've seen legitimate firms get unfair criticism, and we've seen scam operations get exposed too late. Our goal is simple: protect traders from making costly mistakes.
The complaints about TraderScale follow a familiar pattern — one we've documented before with other problematic firms. Let's look at what traders are actually saying.
What Users Are Saying
Reddit User Report
r/FuturesTrading, December 2024
"TraderScale is a scam"
— u/Frederiksberg_, Reddit [source ↗]
This comment appeared in a discussion thread about prop firm experiences. While a single comment doesn't prove fraud, it prompted us to investigate further.
Community Patterns We've Observed:
- •Multiple users in trading forums warning others about TraderScale
- •Reports of accounts being closed without adequate explanation
- •Difficulty reaching support when disputing payout denials
- •Limited verified payout proofs compared to established competitors
Note: We're actively monitoring for more user reports. If you have experience with TraderScale,contact us.
Red Flags We Identified
Based on user reports and our analysis, here are the concerns that have been raised about TraderScale:
Limited Payout Transparency
Few verified withdrawal proofs compared to established firms like Apex or TopStep. Legitimate prop firms typically showcase thousands of verified payouts.
User Account Issues
Reports of accounts being closed or payouts denied without clear explanations that traders can understand or dispute.
Communication Problems
Traders report difficulty reaching support during disputes. Response times and resolution processes appear inconsistent.
Terms & Conditions Concerns
Vague rules that may be enforced retroactively. This is a pattern we've seen with other problematic prop firms(see our Funding Ticks investigation).
Company Information
Limited public information about ownership, company registration, and operational history compared to transparent competitors.
Pattern Recognition
The complaint pattern matches what we've seen with other firms that later had serious issues. Early warning signs often predict larger problems.
What We Don't Know Yet
Fair & Balanced Disclosure:
- We have not tested TraderScale ourselves (yet)
- These are user reports, not verified claims
- TraderScale may have legitimate explanations for these complaints
- We're monitoring the situation and will update this article
"We believe in fair reporting. If TraderScale wants to respond to these concerns, we'll publish their statement.Contact us to share your side."
The Prop Firm Red Flag Checklist
Use this checklist when evaluating ANY prop firm — not just TraderScale:
If a firm shows 3+ of these signs, proceed with extreme caution.
Our Verdict
VERDICT: PROCEED WITH EXTREME CAUTION
Based on emerging user reports, we cannot recommend TraderScale at this time.
Until we see:
- Verified payout proofs from multiple independent sources
- Response to user complaints and improved communication
- Greater transparency about company operations
We advise traders to consider established alternatives with proven track records.
Verified Alternatives
Prop Firms With Proven Track Records
Take Profit Trader
- PRO account = Instant funding
- 80/20 profit split
- No time limits
- 4.5/5 Trustpilot
Apex Trader Funding
- $150M+ paid to traders
- Fast payouts (24-48h)
- Transparent rules
- 4.7/5 Trustpilot
The 5%ers
- Instant funding available
- Scale up to $4M
- Forex & Metals specialist
- 4.6/5 Trustpilot
Don't risk your money on unverified firms.
Compare 50+ prop firms with verified payout records:
Compare All Prop FirmsStay Informed
We're Continuing to Monitor TraderScale
This investigation is ongoing. We'll update this article as new information emerges.
- →If TraderScale responds to these concerns, we'll publish their statement
- →If we receive more user reports, we'll add them here
- →If the situation improves, we'll update our verdict
Have you traded with TraderScale?
Share your experience (positive or negative) to help other traders make informed decisions.
Contact Us